Kazimierz Kutz, through its extremely hostile statements against the Dąbrowa Basin has become a symbol of hatred toward the Silesian region. Do Kutz actually deserved such an opinion? Here is a sample of his work:
But the border river, which separates Russia from the German advance, and before the war from Silesia Basin is the most important boundary in my life. It fell behind her misery to Silesia. Here are touching two civilizations: the Latin and Byzantine. My world was blinded to the German model, it was ruled familijność and industriousness. On the other side reigned cunning, bribery and informing. And this world, in uniforms and suits UB party apparatchiks, entered the war in Silesia and trampled him into the ground. Commune, in the worst its release. Enough, then you do not understand that Silesia is for decades did not want to understand it. This family in front of them insurgents, including mine, fled to Germany. Today, civilization can not see the differences here and there blocks, but they are not able to hide my childhood memories. There were mountaineers, we Hanysy for them. Second Republic was so clever that scaliła these worlds are not in a body, only PRL palnęła civilization and made a foolish province. Asia and Europe combined. Unfortunately, the author of this text there was the word he gave his famous fobiom, very deceptive in describing the reality of those years. This is a description of the supersaturated negative emotions, while Kutz uncomfortable though many of the true facts of that period zamiótł just under the carpet to visitors (readers) do not see them. Yes it did in this "world lepionym the German model?
Tear down this black and white, unreal image borderland described by Kutz, you can very easily - just to mention Silesians who helped the Germans during the occupation in filling offices and "introducing the order" in the Dabrowa Basin. Suffered as a result of both the family and the Polish Jews. What do you feel with their own shops threw their Volksdeutsch behind Brynicy not difficult to guess. Volksliste signed by some 90% of the Silesian, 40 thousand. served in the Wehrmacht, today said that they did it "fear", in order, but it probably does not explain those who served the Germans eager? Looking at the world in the way Kutz could spin on the basis of far-reaching generalizations and accusations.
There are also figures on the participation of residents in the Dąbrowa Basin resistance. Here cooperation with Germany, people are rather highly abhorred. It is precisely in such difficult moments, it turns out who really has the character, and character who only . Association of White Eagle, AK, PPS-GL, a large representation, and also, unfortunately, many victims, but no it can for some very important because that's were the only Polish "Asians" and the wilderness which was then attacked Poland (concentration camps, burning people in furnaces, torture device by the Gestapo, the pseudo medical experiments, rape, robbery, racism in the worst form) is like those "Europeans" carrying the torch of civilization, its fine ..
K. Kutz in their description of the family also praised the rebels, but it eluded him where the insurgents were getting support for those who took it failed, first and foremost the creation of those who fought there then. Insurgent "Silesian" was also Sosnowiec Kiepura Zagłębiaków and many others, risked his life but did not have to.
Brynica - a legendary river, for centuries the border between the countries and regions.
Still with reference to the earlier - in addition to the Silesian who behaved shamefully towards the DS at that time (probably from material motives), there were some who worked in the resistance movement. You must mention this because they simply must. There was even a joint Army division, because the world is not as easy as if he wanted to see some people, and people are different everywhere (egoists and altruists, wise and less wise, honest and thieves). Strange The age that this man is not yet time to grow up so banal truths. Any extreme judgments kontrreakcję cause, in this entry is not a way to avoid criticism and to draw various Silesians facts from the past to demonstrate the absurdity of what he wrote Kutz, but for clarity I repeat once again - the black sheep goes everywhere, and the GS and the DS in every corner of the world so careful with generalizations.
Communists from Silesia
visionary world in terms of black and white Kutz, of course, also forgot about the Communists in Silesia, podlizujących the Stalinists so much that they even changed the name of Katowice, with their participation in the Stalinogrod. Speech by Mr Morcinka in the Sejm of 1953 is quite cabaret today: here to greet the victorious troops Ślązak Comrade Stalin. No wonder that the Silesian, hiding in her heart deep gratitude to Comrade Stalin is a great, heroic city wanted to rename the Stalinogrod
governor of Silesian-Dąbrowa during ubeckim was also a native of Silesia, whom it hired Ziętek at home? Some concrete numbers, data based on documents? Is this "communism at its worst," it was E. Gierek? Against the background of what is happening in the different parts of the Polish and the background of the then Communist Party apparatchiks he specifically did not stand up against, and there are those who say the contrary. Kutz, however, and none knew their numbers and statistics were never needed him. It is worth mentioning the way that Mr Kutz when he called this communism Kuc yet so do not abhor - already during their studies to work on the board of the university ZMP, and even later was associated as one who, rather close to the people's power, not as the creator of the opposition. The sudden explosion of anti-Kutz at just after 1989 seems so very convincingly.
Silesia and that is holy and cursed
antyzagłębiowskich Kutz wrote many texts, gave many interviews. The TVP "Wesoło or sad .." also often referred to the Dąbrowa Basin. His callers invited to the studio sometimes it toning, Andrzej Drawicz said that it looked wrong, Feliks Netz explicitly said that what he does not understand at the Silesian This zapiekłość against Basin. Kutz, however, gave her and the crowd gathered in Katowice studio applauded. A glass may be half full or half empty depends on who wants to see her, Kazimierz Kutz always looked at Sosnowiec and ZD malignant eye and wanted to see themselves in this region the worst things ...
Upper familok characteristic of this region, K. Kutz grew up in a family like Szopienice (now the district of Katowice).
To this day, is indeed quite Silesians many who throw mud at the Basin Dabrowski any occasion. Maybe because I like to brag about is not too much what it is attacking the competition. The other cities disliked by them (especially about Warsaw) also happen to write them a variety of strange stories, and probably do it the same person. Perhaps this manner due to excessive fat diet at the Silesian population poniektórych GSL? Gastryczni People are just supposed to tray. Man gastric Kutz which undoubtedly is in his stories, however, went a little too far. Does anyone imagine that the derived the Basin Janusz Gajos or write any, Jacek Cygan Silesians comments? Do not write them, perhaps because it is a different mentality, so more Asian .
Pennants in the wind
After 1989, there is many who suddenly burned with great reluctance to outgoing communism. Kutz movies go around the regime's money, who lived in those days, wealthy and comfortable, too, began to manifest his reluctance to the previous system. But he did it in a rather clever way, it is often wplątując unfortunately Region dąbrowski. Bad is the Communists were in the Basin, and on his beloved Silesia themselves anti-communists - so it more or less flew. Well, if they were so anti as Mr Kutz is actually the mainstay of Silesia was "anti-Communists."
From the smallest towns in Łódź and Warsaw, the Commune was everywhere, then their people. Cooperated with those who had no ideological resistance, and was tempted by their power, influence and money. Went for anyone is indeed all countries of the former Eastern bloc. In the East German communists ruled, raging stasis, shot at people crossing the wall. After opening the archives of the local security police, it turned out that a great percent of the population reported on its neighbors (and it seems Germany is such a decent nation.) Claiming that Silesia was an island is so so naive that the author probably did not believe in fairy tales that served by another. It looked as if the text is the result of personal complexes, the director, the desire to fit into a new system ... Jerzy Urban (former neighbor of the estate for Kutz peerelowskich celebrities, known as the Bay of Pigs Red) once said that whatever the circumstances, always falls on their feet and he fared well, both under communism and after 1989. Undoubtedly, Kazimierz Kutz has a similar ability to always fall on their feet, just as if sometimes a little ashamed of that.
Kutz views on the Basin began to evolve over time, no longer wants to share, will cooperate. Perhaps this is revealed to his local patriotism in the new circumstances. In the interest of Katowice is a fact that remained in the Sosnowiec region so Kutz did not exacerbate disputes. Or maybe he just got tired of this aggression, and even criticism of him ZD is already good for nothing ... This cited the need beginning of the text ("Returns Hanysa" - Weekly Politics - No. 31) dates back to 2002 and see if there is an attempt to withdraw from the barricades, which he previously usypał (formerly they were the "be" and now it's here and there blocks .) If it did not do it, someone might ask, inquiring why not work on the separation of these two regions, after all, after the collapse of communism in Poland it is very possible. Anyway, this question is asked (to date) on both sides of Brynicy by various "evil separatists".
"I am for or even against" - K. Kutz on the march was a Palestinian, but the province of Upper Silesia in the historical borders not want to.
It is worth mentioning at the end, although sometimes annoying Kutz texts it is better to have them a considerable distance. And that's because he can very well manage feelings of readers / viewers, and the apparent emotion often be hidden, only cold calculation. I especially recommend that the ZD residents, who were often just a backdrop for K. Kutz needing to prove his anti-communism after 1989. For example, even this passage: This family in front of them insurgents, also mine, fled to Germany. What does it mean that "escaped" and to whom exactly? Was it was a postwar emigration to West Germany Silesians? Probably yes, but because emigration is associated with trips to improve the material conditions (with PRL poor to the rich West Germany ..) so Kutz, "he went insurgents" for better effect. Who in fact did not have mercy on the fate of insurgent families and who will not support anti-communist Kutz, in his righteous indignation ... It was surprising that he himself fled to the FRG.
In the interview, the excerpt was presented for the DS is also such a dramatic description of how to attack the young Soviet soldiers Ślązaczkę (Kutz writes that he instilled in the Communion against ). Of course, any normal person on the state of the victim ... and then you look too kindly look at Kutz (this is a decent man, we have a similar scale of values). Since then, he already leads the reader by the hand where he wants. Meanwhile, in a biographical book, "All that Kutz" is described as a light situation as he defended a student accused a colleague of the ZMP of rape. Well, it comes out that morality also sometimes relative. In a good theater, the idea is to evoke in the viewer's emotions. If the audience is indifferent yawns whether this performance is poor. Kutz as a good director can no doubt create a good presentation - some of them laugh and applaud, others are angry and others cry. He can also freely create positive and negative characters, and ... build your own legend.
Kutz controversy with lyrics a little bit as if to prove that you are not an alien. Practically, this does not even make much sense, but the entry for that person to miss this site could not because I am interested in all the difficult questions (and this is one of the "heavy cases") in relation dąbrowsko-Silesia. It is also always present your point of view that there is no situation that someone has a monopoly on "truth" ... because sometimes you may find that on the other hand, it looks completely different.
0 comments:
Post a Comment